Lost Alumni List from 1958
| First Name | Last Name |
| John | Aherne |
| Earl | Alexander |
| Stanley | Alter |
| George | Anthony |
| Alvin | Appel |
| Harold | Aspesi |
| Joshua | Berman |
| Benjamin | Berman |
| William | Bernstein |
| Stanley | Bloom |
| Martin | Bloom |
| Martin | Braginsky |
| Doris | Brooks |
| Walter | Brown |
| Walter | Budziak |
| Barbara | Cheteyan |
| Isabell | Chin |
| Mary | Chin |
| Donald | Cohen |
| Paul | Cohen |
| Theresa | Conway |
| Marion | Costello |
| Rose | Criscione |
| Daniel | Deitch |
| George | Delegianis |
| Thomas | Dellacorte |
| A. | Demetropoulos |
| Frank | Digiacomo |
| John | Dolan |
| Hana | Dubovy |
| Edward | Duffy |
| Sam | Dwochbabny |
| Sally | Engelberg |
| John | Fallon |
| Edward | Ferguson |
| Angelo | Ferraro |
| James | Finlay |
| Lucienne | Fischer |
| Judith | Friedlander |
| Leon | Gedaly |
| Joseph | Geiger |
| Steven | Geldzahler |
| Herman | Goldschlager |
| Luis | Gomez |
| Michael | Goodstein |
| Philip | Gottesman |
| Carl | Gray |
| Allan | Greenblatt |
| Anita | Haas |
| Harold | Heller |
| Murray | Hellman |
| Henderson | Hicks |
| Alfred | Jacobson |
| Alan | Johnson |
| Frederic | King |
| Marlean | Korngold |
| Sam | Kristol |
| Eli | Kuperman |
| Annette | Kustoff |
| Jeramiah | Larkin |
| Claire | Laufer |
| Frank | Lawton |
| Nathaniel | Leichter |
| William | Lentini |
| John | Leon |
| Robert | Leven |
| Eric | Levi |
| David | Levy |
| Jerome | Lifshitz |
| Daniel | Liker |
| William | Lipton |
| Donald | Mandell |
| Joseph | Marks |
| Lynne | Miller |
| S. | Mishehyshyn |
| James | Murphy |
| A. | Naccarella |
| Louis | Nathan |
| Larry | Nick |
| John | O'Neill |
| Ralph | Oppenheim |
| Anthony | Patinella |
| Sybil | Peskowitz |
| Edith | Portnay |
| Donald | Price |
| Jerry | Putterman |
| Jack | Rapp |
| Frank | Raso |
| Bernard | Ratowitz |
| Phyllis | Ritter |
| Thomas | Rooney |
| Martin | Rosenberg |
| Burton | Sanders |
| Joseph | Sangiorgio |
| Joseph | Schwartz |
| Harvey | Shapiro |
| Bernard | Siegel |
| Lawrence | Siegel |
| Fred | Silverman |
| Harold | Silverman |
| Eleanor | Singer |
| Robert | Slepian |
| Vivian | Small |
| Eugene | Solomon |
| Seymour | Speigel |
| Selma | Stark |
| Nadia | Stasiuk |
| Jerome | Stengel |
| Joseph | Sullivan |
| Carrie | Sulzbacher |
| Marsha | Tekuzener |
| Edith | Thomas |
| David | Toll |
| Jane | Tumilowicz |
| Steve | Vlahos |
| Stanley | Weintraub |
| Albert | Weiss |
| Dennis | White |
| Dorothy | Youngman |
| Max | Zidile |
| Michael | Zielinski |
